Can We Survive Technology? - Intuition Stories - Speculative Machines and Us

intuition
stories

Stories for teaching, learning, and research: From electric brains to generative AI, explore intuition in digital computing histories through 40 key concepts, initiatives, milestones, systems, and publications. Uncover how questions about sensing, thinking, and speculating animate current debates on machine intelligence.
Can We Survive Technology?
John von Neumann essay addressing the ambivalence of twentieth century technological progress
Can We Survive Technology?

Can We Survive Technology?

‘Can We Survive Technology?’ is a 1955 essay by the mathematician, computer pioneer, and Manhattan Project member John von Neumann, published in Fortune magazine.

In this influential piece, von Neumann reflects on the links among three major mid-twentieth century scientific advancements in which he had a direct hand: nuclear power, digital computing, and numerical weather prediction. What links these technologies, he claims, is that ‘all are intrinsically useful’ but nonetheless ‘lend themselves to destruction’ (von Neumann, 1955: 11-12).

Of particular concern is how atmospheric modelling enables not only more accurate daily weather forecasting but also growing capacities for weather modification and climate control.

With high-speed digital computing is possible, von Neumann acknowledges, to ‘carry out analyses needed to predict results and intervene at any desired scale’. Beyond the existing technologies of “rain making” (seeding clouds with chemical compounds such as silver iodide), ‘a new ice age or tropical era’ could be created (1955: 11).

Anticipating the long-term consequences of a general cooling or heating the atmosphere, however, is a complex and indeterminate undertaking; it is not immediately obvious which interventions would be beneficial or harmful and to ‘which regions of the earth’ (1955: 10).

Once global climate control is actualised, von Neumann speculates, ‘[p]resent awful possibilities of nuclear warfare may give way to others even more awful’ (1955: 16) – in ways that will make existing geopolitical involvements seem straightforward.

To address this coming crisis, von Neumann suggests that ‘we must not only look at relevant facts, but also engage in some speculation’ (1955: 1). We must intuit the implications of potential technological developments to come, with attention to the exploitation of nuclear energy, increasing automation, and growing capacities for climate warfare.

In addition to framing post-war technological advancement as ‘an ambivalent achievement’ (1955: 12), von Neumann’s essay raises broader questions about the meaning and utility of speculation, intuition, forecasting, prediction, and control in a nuclear age.

Given that the transformations associated with technological progress inevitably ‘create instability’, their wider consequences ‘are not a priori predictable’ and experience shows, he argues, that ‘most contemporary “first guesses” concerning them are wrong’ (1955: 16).

The fragile global situation therefore calls for different modalities of scientific and political governance. More speculative, pragmatic, and responsive forms of navigating possible technological and geopolitical developments and their uncertain implications are required – ones that, in mobilising novel human-machine synergies to sense and respond to feedback, resonate with cybernetic imaginaries.

Artificial intuition
AI concept proposing how machines might simulate intuition for rapid, creative, or uncertain decisions
Artificial intuition
Neural network
AI architecture inspired by brains, enabling learning from data through layered connections
Neural network
Post-cybernetic logic
Leveraging computational uncertainty to generate value
Post-cybernetic logic