First order cybernetics
The 1940s witnessed the consolidation of first order cybernetics as an ‘interdisciplinary science of communication, computation and automatic control’ (Conway and Siegelman, 2005: xi) that would lay vital groundwork for the nascent fields of cognitive science and artificial intelligence.
In the United States, the Macy conferences in cybernetics, inaugurated at the Beekman Hotel in New York City in 1942, brought together leading mathematicians including Norbert Weiner and John von Neumann with the pioneering neuroscientists Warren McCulloch and Walter Pitts, the information theorist Claude Shannon, and the anthropologists Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson, among others.
In Britain, the Ratio Club, which met in London between 1949 and 1958, enabled wide-ranging cybernetic conversations among physiologists, mathematicians, and engineers, including the mathematician Alan Turing, as well as the neurophysiologist W. Grey Walter and the psychiatrist W. Ross Ashby.
The 1948 publication of Wiener’s best-selling book, Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and Machine, pioneered a statistical probabilities-based approach to communications engineering and introduced the concept of “feedback” as what links humans and certain kinds of machines.
We might note the partial resonances between cybernetic accounts of feedback and philosophies of intuition. For Weiner, neither human beings nor intelligent machines are isolated systems: both possess ‘sense organs’ – ‘a special apparatus for collecting information from the outer world’ (Wiener, 1950: 26) which is fed back into the system to inform future operations.
The cultural theorist Lauren Berlant, in turn, describes intuition as involving ‘sensual data gathering’ through which we navigate the present and feel-forward into the future. Intuition involves bodies ‘continually busy judging their environments and responding to the atmospheres in which they find themselves’ (Berlant, 2011: 15).
On both sides of the Atlantic, cybernetics was more than a narrow computational engineering enterprise; it was, as the sociologist Andrew Pickering contends, a new way of thinking about the world premised on a ‘non-modern ontology’, in which reality is always ‘in the making’ and ‘people and things are not so different after all’ (Pickering, 2010: 18).
While cybernetics is usually framed as emerging from Second World War military technologies and post-war digital computing, the media historian Bernard Dionysius Geoghegan (2023) suggests that liberal technocrats’ inter-war visions of social welfare delivered via “neutral” communication techniques shaped the informatic interventions of both WWII and the Cold War.
Stretching cybernetics’ timeline to encompass the 1920s and 1930s also foregrounds the importance of colonial relations, eugenics, and indigenous cultures to the rise of cybernetic methods and epistemologies – while shifting the focus of analysis from engineering, computing, and statistics to anthropology, psychology, linguistics, and critical theory (Geoghegan, 2023).